Handyman Butt Plug Test and Review

I tested the Handyman butt plug from Mr. Hankey’s Toys earlier this year and it took the first spot on Fistingday list of the best fist butt plugs.

The quality is simply amazing and way above anything else available now. I’ve made a comparison later on in this review which details some of the differences between it and a similar product.

You can get the Handyman plug in 4 different sizes, a wide range of cool colors, and different firmnesses. I would highly recommend getting the “Medium firm” which is the firmness I found the best. Both when it comes to ease of penetration and how comfortable it feels to use.

I know it’s a little expensive but the quality and details make it worth it in my mind.


  • Amazing details on the hand
  • Platinum-cured silicone feels so nice
  • Lots of customization options
  • Huge base makes it impossible to slip in entirely


  • No suction-cup option (It could have been used as a fist dildo)
  • It’s expensive

Overall, the highest-rated fisting butt plug I’ve ever tested and seen in my life and I’ve seen a lot of sex toys.

You can buy it at mrhankeystoys.com click “Shop” and then “Realistic” and find it on the list.

Read Full Review Below:

Design and Aesthetics

When I first laid eyes on the Handyman Butt Plug, I knew its design was unlike any typical sex toy. It blended a sophisticated design with a touch of realism that instantly grabbed my attention.

Texture and Material

I was immediately impressed with the quality of the material. Platinum-cured silicone is the gold standard here – it’s skin-safe and meets the ISO 10993-10 standard for irritability and sensitivity, which is a big deal for me.

The texture felt realistic, with vein detail and skin details that added a lifelike touch, enhancing the sensory experience. I was informed that this toy goes for a natural tan color, aiming to mimic realistic skin to the closest detail.

Visual Appeal

As for the visual aspect, let’s just say the Handyman doesn’t shy away from a bit of creativity. The design takes inspiration from fantasy and sci-fi elements, but it still maintains a natural tan color that looks pretty darn close to the real thing.

The handmade aspect of it shines through with fine attention to detail that makes each piece unique. It’s not every day that you come across a butt plug that’s as much a piece of art as it is a pleasure product.

Sizing Options

Please make sure you know what you can handle before going for the larger versions! They are freaking huge and you’ll be surprised how big they are. Take a standard drinking can in your hand while you take a look at the picture below to get a sense of just how big they are.

Usage and Care

When it comes to Handyman Butt Plugs from Hankey’s Toys, I’m super careful to enjoy the experience and keep my toys in tip-top condition. Here’s the lowdown on how I use them and maintain them for high durability and safety.

How to Use

I always start with choosing the right size and type of Handyman Butt Plug for my comfort level and experience. Hankey’s Toys are known for their realistic textures and custom options, like selectable firmness and strap-on ring size, which makes them versatile for various experiences.

Here’s my step-by-step process:

  • Preparation: I find that using ample thick water-based lube makes insertion smoother and more comfortable. Thick water-based lube is long-lasting and doesn’t dry out quickly, making it ideal to use with Hankey’s silicone toys. Just be sure to avoid using silicone-based lube with silicone toys, as it can degrade the material. For compatibility, I’d go for a water-based lube instead.
  • Position: To insert the plug, I often use the “silent duck” hand position, where I press my fingers together and bend them at the knuckles, resembling a duck’s beak. It’s a gentle way to start, as it resembles the tapered tip of the Handyman.
  • Insertion: Gradually, I push the plug in, taking it slow and stopping if there’s any discomfort. Once the widest part passes through my sphincter, the narrower section slides in fairly easily, and the flared base prevents any too-deep explorations.
  • Wear: I take care not to wear the plug for too long on my first go. I started with short 30-minute periods, working up as I gauged how my body responded.


Keeping my Handyman clean after use ensures it stays odorless and safe for the next round. Here’s what I do:

  • Cleaning: First, I use plenty of sex toy cleaner – it’s specially formulated to be safe for my body and effective on the toy. I give it a good rinse with warm water and then apply the cleaner.
  • Disinfecting: Sometimes I mix it up with mild soap and warm water for a thorough wash. If Hankey’s recommends it, I might soak the toy in a 10% bleach solution for disinfection, followed by a thorough rinse – but I always check the care instructions specific to the toy first.
  • Drying and Storage: After cleaning, I let it air dry completely before storing it away. Keeping it in a cool, dry place ensures no unwanted moisture can wreak havoc. Plus, Hankey’s toys are durable, so as long as I take care, they should last me a long time.

Remembering these tips and tricks, I’ve found my Handyman Butt Plugs to be an enjoyable and staple part of my adventures, while staying hygienic and in great condition.

Product Details and Purchasing

I’ve found that when it comes to unique and perhaps unconventional adult toys, it’s crucial to know exactly what you’re getting and where to get it. Here’s a lowdown on the Handyman Butt Plug details and how you can make it yours.

Brand and Manufacturing

Hankey’s Toys is the brand behind the Handyman Butt Plug, known for its high-grade platinum silicone products that balance quality with fantasy designs.

I noticed they tout a reputation for durability and detail in their range of fantasy dildos. Each Handyman Butt Plug is marketed as handmade, which suggests a level of craftsmanship you don’t always find in mass-produced alternatives.

Compared Against the Mister B Fist

I know it can be hard to justify the $125 price tag of the Handyman butt plug when you can get a product like the Mister B fist for $39.

But take a look at the comparison picture below and notice the molding lines on the Mister B fist.

You can clearly see them running all along the fist and the base. Now look at the fine details on the Handyman and see the difference between them.

I know that not all care about realism which is fine and then I would highly recommend the Mister B Fist butt plug.

My Thoughts About the Handyman Butt Plug

Overall, the best fist butt plug that I’ve seen and tested and that says a lot. I’ve tested hundreds of sex toys in my life which makes it quite an achievement.

You can buy the Handyman from mrhankeystoys.com click “Shop” and then “Realistic” and find it on the list.