Best Fist Butt Plug

A butt plug the size and shape of a fist is the ultimate end goal for all anal play. I’ve found 3 different options that suits a wide range of pockets and buttholes 😊

#1 Handyman Butt Plug

The Handyman Butt Plug is an innovative adult toy designed for you who enjoy exploring unique shapes and sensations. Featuring a hand-like design with slightly curled fingers, this plug offers you a very stimulating and rewarding experience once it’s in.

It’s handmade from platinum cured silicone which the best and safest material for sex toys.


  • Very high-quality molding
  • Handmade from silicone
  • Lots of realistic details
  • Available in 4 sizes and 3 skin tones
  • Select between firm and soft


  • It’s fairly expensive

Mr. Hankey is the master behind the Handyman butt plug and it’s just as good as their world-famous dildos. You can find it in the link below under the “Realistic dildos” section.

#2 Mister B All Black Fist Butt Plug

This high-quality butt plug is shaped like a clenched fist and provides an intense sensation of fullness and stretch.

Made from body-safe PVC material, the Mister B All Black Fist Butt Plug is easy to clean, durable, and compatible with water-based lubricants. Plus, its sleek black design adds an air of sophistication to your intimate play.


  • A “pure” fist butt plug
  • Very cheap
  • Wide base
  • Looks awesome


  • Not the best quality
  • Fairly limited details
  • Not beginner friendly

Mister B is all about getting punch fucked right in the butt and it does it pretty damn well. It does require a whole lot of practice and the learning curve is super steep compared to the other products on this list.

#3 The Stuffer Fisting Hand

This is described as a dildo but the end suction cup acts just like a butt plug base so I’ve included it on this list. It can be found in a longer version where the arm is included as the shaft. I’ve reviewed that on Fistingday earlier this year at The Fister dildo.

It’s similar designed to the Handyman with fingers pointing forward making it easier to insert and a better choice for less experienced fisters.


  • Fingers first fist plug/dildo
  • Can be used as a fisting dildo
  • Fairly cheap


  • Washed out details
  • Made with PVC

The details on The Stuffer Fisting Hand feels kind of washed out and it’s clear that they haven’t put as much efford into making as many details as possible. This does reflect in the price with is 1/3 of the Handyman plug.

Not ready to buy a fist butt plug yet? Learn more about them before you pick one.

Selecting the Right Lube

When using fist butt plugs or any other adult toys designed for anal play, proper lubrication is paramount for several reasons:

  • Comfort and Pleasure: The anal area does not naturally produce lubrication like other parts of the body, so applying generous amounts of lube makes for a more comfortable and pleasurable experience by reducing friction between toy and body.
  • Safety: The skin in the anal area is delicate and vulnerable to tears or injuries if not adequately lubricated. Utilizing lube reduces this risk, making the experience both safer and more enjoyable for all parties involved.
  • Easier Insertion: Fist butt plugs may be larger and more challenging to insert than other types of plugs, making the experience smoother for users. Lubrication helps make inserting these plugs easier, providing them with a smoother experience overall.

When selecting a lubricant for fist butt plugs, it’s essential to select one that is compatible with the material of the toy. Water-based lubricants tend to be reliable options since they work well on various materials and are easy to clean up afterward. However, be sure to steer clear of silicone-based lubricants when working with silicone toys since these can damage them.

Enjoy Your New Toy

For a comfortable and secure fist butt plug experience, follow these best practices:

  1. Begin Slowly: For those new to using fist butt plugs, it is essential to start slowly and gradually increase size until you feel comfortable with the sensation. Start with a smaller, more manageable size so that you can become accustomed to its sensation.
  2. Warm Up: Before using a fist butt plug, engage in ample foreplay or use smaller toys to help relax muscles and prepare the body for insertion.
  3. Lubrication: Lubrication is essential for comfort and safety when playing with toys. Use a generous amount of compatible lubricant on both the toy and yourself or your partner, to ensure both are in optimal comfort and grip.
  4. Communication: If you’re using a fist butt plug with someone special, maintain open communication throughout the experience. Make sure to discuss boundaries, comfort levels, and any concerns beforehand. Throughout the experience itself, regularly check in with your partner to guarantee they’re at ease and enjoying themselves fully.
  5. Take Your Time: Insert the fist butt plug slowly and gently, allowing your body to adjust to its size and shape. If you experience discomfort or pain, stop immediately and give yourself extra time for relaxation before continuing.
  6. Clean and Store: After each use, thoroughly clean your fist butt plug with warm water and mild soap or a toy cleaner, then store it away from direct sunlight and dust in an airy, dry location.

By following these best practices, you can guarantee a secure, comfortable, and enjoyable experience with a fist butt plug. Always remember to prioritize consent, communication, and proper preparation prior to engaging in any intimate activities.

Fist Butt Plug or Fist Dildo?

The difference between butt plugs and dildos are often very large and it’s very clear what you need to buy. But fist butt plugs can often by used as a fisting dildo due to the size of the hand and the narrow wrist part.

I’ve selected the Handyman plug as the best option in the fist plug category but the base can easily be used as a grip like a dildo and used in that way.

There are some really long and well-made fist dildos that I want you to take a look at if you want to go all-in and find your own limit.

My Final Thoughts About Fist Butt Plugs

There is no doubt that using a fist butt plug has a very steep learning curve and I would highly recommend taking your time to build up to the size of a human hand.

That being set – There is simply no way to describe the feeling of being filled up to your limit like you do with a hand butt plug.

It’s a recommendation from me if you’re into fisting and wish to venture into anal fisting.