4 Best Fist Dildo 2024

A fisting dildo is a great way to experience fisting without the need of a partner. Or why not share it with a partner and enjoy it together.

I’ve tested quite a few different dildos shaped like fists in the past 15 years that I’ve been working as a sex toy tester and I’ve created a list of the best ones.

Some of the dildos are a little expensive but you generally get what you pay for.

These are the Best Fisting Dildos

#1 Gut Puncher

The Gut Puncher is a handmade fist dildo made by Mr. Hankey’s and it’s got so much awesome stuff going on for it.

If you’ve ever owned a dildo from Mr. Hankey’s then you know how good the quality is and have seen all the small details that makes it standout from the crowd. If it’s your first one than prepare for greatness.

You’re going to love the Gut Puncher, but make sure you can handle the size!

Pros:

  • Made with high-quality silicone
  • Select between 3 sizes
  • Select between 3 colors
  • 2 Firmness options
  • Handmade premium quality

Cons:

  • The softest option is a little too squishy
  • A smaller option would be ideal for beginners
  • It’s pretty expensive

I love the stuff Mr. Hankey’s make and I can’t recommend their dildos enough. Just make sure your eyes don’t get too greedy and buy something your vagina or anus can’t handle.

I recommend the Gut Puncher if you want the best quality Fisting dildo.

*The link below leads you to the front page of Mr. Hankey’s Toys, just click the “Realistic dildos” and find it.


#2 Belladonna Fist

The Belladonna Magic Hand as it’s called by Doc Johnson who made it is a molded version of Belladonna’s hand.

It’s 12-inches long and the thickest point at the knuckles is around 8.5-inches in circumference.

There are longs of tiny details around the entire hand and forearm which it pretty cool.

I personally love the flex and stretch in the hand which makes it pretty easy to insert.

Pros:

  • Replica of a real hand
  • 12-inch long
  • Good flex in the material
  • Very cheap

Cons:

  • It’s made with PVC

Overall, a really great fisting dildo that’s ideal if you’re on a budget or if you simply wish to enjoy Belladonna’s hand inside your body.

You can read my full Belladonna Magic Hand review if you wish to learn more about it.

I recommend the Belladonna Magic Hand if you’re after the best budget fisting dildo!


#3 The Fister

Looking for a fist dildo with an entire arm? Guess what – You’ve found it! The Fister from Master Series have a 15” insertable length and a 9.5-inch circumference.

It’s no joke but the best option if you’re after a long and slender fisting dildo.

It does lack some of the fine details as the other options but you’re getting a whole lot of fun for less than $90.

Pros:

  • Huge fist with long arm
  • Fair price
  • Suction-cup base

Cons:

  • Made with PVC
  • Not many fine details

The Fister is for you if you wish to get fisted as deep as possible. This is by no means a beginner friendly fisting dildo but requires training and lot of lube!

I recommend The Fister if you’re after a really long fist dildo.


#4 Dana’s Grip

Not really a fist dildo but it’s such a cool design that I’ve included it on this list just to show you it as an option.

You can get it in 4 different sizes with the smallest being very beginner friendly and all the way to whole shit that’s freaking huge!

Its design is quite unique with the two hands holding a giant cock, so you’re kind of getting triple penetrated when you use it.

Pros:

  • Lots of size options
  • Beginner friendly
  • Lots of amazing details
  • Handmade with silicone

Cons:

  • Fairly expensive
  • Not a “true” fist dildo

If you’re in to fisting but having a hard time getting started with a “full-size” fist dildo then the Dana’s Grip might be the perfect choice for you. Mr. Hankey’s does also have a really nice fist butt plug that could be of interest for you.

I’ve written a full Dana’s Grip dildo review if you’re interested in it.

I recommend Dana’s Grip if you’re too afraid of the size of the other fist dildos.

*The link below leads you to the front page of Mr. Hankey’s Toys, just click the “Realistic dildos” and find it.


Still not sure what to get? Read on and learn more about special fisting dildos so you can choose one based on knowledge and not what some BS marketing tells you to buy.  

What is a Fisting dildo?

Fisting dildos are a unique type of sex toy that are designed to stretch the hole of your anus or vagina. They come in the shape of a hand, resembling a duck’s beak, and are much larger than regular dildos. Using a fist dildo requires practice and patience, so it is not recommended for beginners. It is important to use plenty of lubricant when using this type of toy, as it can cause discomfort if used without proper preparation.

When using a fisting dildo, it is important to go slowly and carefully. Start by inserting one finger at a time until you feel comfortable with the size and shape of the toy. Once you have inserted the entire fist-shaped dildo, you can then move it around inside your body in order to stimulate different areas. Be sure to take breaks throughout the process in order to avoid any potential pain or discomfort. With practice and patience, fisting dildos can provide an incredibly pleasurable experience for those who enjoy anal or vaginal stimulation.

Where can I Buy Fist Dildos?

When it comes to buying a dildo, there are many options available. The first step is to decide what purpose the dildo will serve and how much stretching your hole can handle. After that, you can choose the material and shape that best suits you. There are many online stores where you can easily order dildos discreetly and quickly. Mr. Hankey’s Dildos is one of the most well-known online stores for purchasing dildos. They offer a wide selection of materials, shapes, sizes, and colors to suit any preference or need.

The ordering process at Mr. Hankey’s Dildos is simple and secure. You can browse through their selection of products on their website and select the one that best fits your needs. Once you have chosen your desired product, you can add it to your cart and proceed with checkout securely using PayPal or credit card payment methods. All orders are shipped in discreet packaging so no one will know what’s inside! With fast shipping times and excellent customer service, Mr. Hankey’s Dildos is an ideal place to buy a fist dildo from!

How do I use it?

Using a fisting dildo can be an exciting and pleasurable experience, but it requires some extra steps to ensure that it is done safely. Before using the dildo, make sure to use plenty of lubricant on both the toy and your body. This will help reduce friction and make insertion easier. It is also important to take your time when inserting the dildo; pushing too hard or too fast can cause discomfort or even injury.

Once you are ready to insert the fisting dildo, start by slowly pushing it in with one hand while using your other hand to guide it in. You may need to adjust your grip as you go along, depending on how deep you want the toy to go. Make sure that you are comfortable before continuing further. Once fully inserted, you can experiment with different speeds and angles for maximum pleasure. When finished, make sure to clean the toy thoroughly before storing it away for next time!

Prepare for Penetration

Before attempting to use a fisting dildo or an actual fist, it is important to warm up the body and prepare for the experience. Start with smaller toys that you are used to, such as vibrators or dildos. This will help your body become accustomed to the sensation of penetration and make it easier for you to relax when it comes time for insertion. Once you feel comfortable and relaxed, lube up your choice of hole and begin inserting the toy or fist slowly and gently. Make sure to take breaks if needed, as this can be a strenuous activity. Remember that communication is key throughout the process; if something doesn’t feel right, stop immediately and take a break before continuing. With patience and practice, you can enjoy a safe and pleasurable fisting experience!

The Penetration

Inserting a toy or hand into your body can be an incredibly pleasurable experience, but it is important to take things slow and use plenty of high-quality fisting lube. Before attempting insertion, make sure that you are relaxed and comfortable. If you feel any pain during the process, stop immediately and try again another time. It is also important to remember that you don’t have to insert the entire toy or hand inside of you if it doesn’t feel comfortable. Instead, keep track of how far you were able to insert the toy/hand and gradually increase the depth until you can successfully fit the entire toy/hand inside of you.

When inserting a toy or hand into your body, it is important to go at your own pace and listen to your body. Don’t rush yourself and take breaks if needed. Remember that there should never be any pain involved in this process; if there is, then stop immediately and try again another time when you are more relaxed. With patience and practice, inserting a toy or hand into your body can become an enjoyable experience that will help bring pleasure and satisfaction.

The “Aftermath”

Cleaning a fisting dildo is an important part of taking proper care of your sex toys. Without proper cleaning, your toy will likely wear out early and you could even get an infection. Many toys, such as those made from PVC, are porous materials that can easily harbor bacteria and cannot be sterilized. This means it is even more important to make sure they are properly cleaned.

Fortunately, cleaning these toys is quite easy and does not require any special cleaners or solutions. Anti-bacterial soap and warm water will do the trick just fine. Be sure to thoroughly rinse the toy after washing it with soap and warm water to remove any residue that may remain on the surface. Additionally, if you want to take extra precautions, you can use a condom when using the toy for added protection against bacteria and other germs.

Final Conclusion About Selecting Your Next Fist Dildo

There are quite a few really nice dildos shaped like a fist and with a size that will satisfy even the most size hungry hole out there!

I’m personally a huge fan of Mr. Hankey’s dildos which are handmade and made with the best quality materials, but there are other great options if you can’t afford their prices. And please take it slow! Fisting should be fun and NOT painful! Time, lube, and more lube is the keys to a fun dildo fisting experience.